Many journals in our field, perhaps most, anonymise the submissions they send out for review, and pass comments back to authors anonymised in turn: a “double-blind” system. This has always been ROLSI’s practice (at least, it has been under the editorship of the last five editors). But occasionally a reader or potential reviewer raises the question as to why this is preferable to signed reviews, or indeed submissions with the author’s name attached.

Charles Antaki, ROLSI Editor
I thought readers might be interested in a recent e-mail dialogue with a reader on just these issues. Continue reading
















